Should You Date A Godly Woman You’re Not Attracted To? | Bryan Stoudt
Should You Date A Woman You're Not Attracted To

Should You Date A Godly Woman You’re Not Attracted To?

When it comes to dating, lots of Christian guys wonder about the role physical appearance and godly character should play in who they decide to pursue.

In other words, do looks matter?

More specifically, they ask if it's wise to pursue a godly woman they do not find physically attractive in the hopes that they will develop feelings for her over time.

It's a difficult, sensitive topic, but by the end of this article I hope to share a framework that will help you pursue this aspect of godly dating with wisdom.

The Weirdest Dating Advice I Ever Received

It was the weirdest Christian dating advice I had ever received.

One of my friends was telling me about a recently-married, mutual acquaintance who had just two criteria.  I figured simple = good, especially coming from this acquaintance, someone in ministry I respected.

'He wanted a godly woman, obviously' my friend said, 'and she had to look good in a little black dress.'

As a single guy in my early twenties, I found his comment confusing.  On the one hand, putting so much emphasis on appearance seemed really worldly.  But our mutual acquaintance was a pastor I looked up to, and we're supposed to be attracted to someone we're dating... right?

Twenty years later, it's easy to see that our acquaintance's comment was seriously misguided.  But it illustrates the confusion Christian guys are facing in how to evaluate the relative value of physical appearance when dating.

While we cannot - for any reason - approve of objectifying women, the culture around us makes that challenging.  (For men and women.) Movies, television, and the internet are giving us the message that image is everything.  Although most churches and Christian circles acknowledge that message is wrong, sometimes in practice they don't give much guidance.

The Tension Between Character And Physical Appearance

So if you're a single, Christian guy, I can totally see why you're wrestling with this tension.  You want to honor God and the women you date. You don't want to objectify them, and you understand that a woman's character matters way more than her looks.

But you also want to have real desire toward the woman you may marry.  After all, God created beauty.

And yet, you sense that physical appearance can be too important to you at times.  Maybe you struggle with lust or pornography, and sense that your heart has the potential to lead you astray.  (Good call; it does.)

To make things even more complicated, you have some female friends who are seriously godly, but you're not attracted to them.  And you have other female friends who are not so godly, yet - if you're honest - are pretty physically attractive.

For example, one guy shared with me that he's sexually attracted to his girlfriend, yet knows that spiritually she's not in a solid place. He (rightfully) has doubts about the relationship, but is finding it hard to end.

So what do you do with all this?  To sharpen the point of the pencil, let's ask two more specific questions:

  1. What roles do godly character and physical beauty play in pursuing a potential spouse?
  2. Should you date someone you're not attracted to? (Do looks matter in a relationship? Or, should you 'choose' to be attracted to a potential spouse even if you're not?)

To answer these questions, let's look at God's design for beauty, the dangers of beauty in a fallen world, then explore two principles for how to proceed with a godly woman you may not find physically attractive.

Beauty, God's Good Design

It's hard to deny that men are visual creatures.  For example, research shows that for men, vision is the dominant perceptual sense, while in women the different senses are much more balanced.  When women lie in their online dating profiles, it's most often by posting pictures of themselves when they were younger - and thinner.  In other words, women know what (many) guys want. (To be clear, many guys are dishonest, too, and shade the truth.)

But Scripture makes it plain that physical beauty is part of God's good design.  For example, when we meet Rebekah, she's described as a 'young woman... very attractive in appearance'. (Genesis 24:16) And again and again, the Song of Solomon celebrates physical attraction, often in terms that make us blush.

When my wife and I do premarital counseling, we'll often ask couples what first drew them to each other. The guy will always mention her godly character, but eventually admit that 'she was cute'.  (I don't think I've ever heard a woman mention that about a guy.)  Usually, guys feel sheepish when they say that, but they shouldn't.  Guys, God made you that way.

Of course, on a far deeper level, God himself is beautiful. David prayed,

'One thing have I asked of the Lord,
    that will I seek after:
that I may dwell in the house of the Lord
    all the days of my life,
to gaze upon the beauty of the Lord
    and to inquire in his temple.' (Psalm 27:4)

Since we are made in God's image, the physical attractiveness we possess is a reflection of a much greater - and permanent - beauty that God himself possesses. A beauty that has no limits, and will satisfy us forever.

A woman's physical beauty is ultimately one reflection of the beauty of her creator. Put simply, it is part of God's good design, something to be celebrated. And it matters when choosing a potential partner.

I like the way Stephen Altrogge puts it in his article 'Should You "Choose" To Be Attracted To Your Potential Spouse?':

A husband and wife should be spiritually compatible AND physically attracted to each other. This doesn’t mean that the man or woman is a supermodel. Beauty is fleeting, and charm is deceitful, which is why we don’t make those things the primary factors in a relationship. But God created us as both spiritual and physical beings. We are not sexless, spiritual beings. God made us to have flesh and blood. He created us to be attracted to the opposite sex.

So, you should be physically attracted to someone you date, and consider marrying. 

Warning Label

At the same time, guys, in a fallen world we know physical beauty should have a warning label. And throughout the bible, it often does.

The same bible that praises physical beauty also contains tragic stories of its misuse.  Samson and Delilah (Judges 16), David and Bathsheba (2 Samuel 11), Solomon and his thousand-women-harem that 'turned away his heart after other gods' (1 Kings 11:3-4).

Proverbs states the danger with classic simplicity:

'Charm is deceitful, and beauty is vain.' (31:30)

Beauty is vain in the sense that it will fade.  As Pastor Matt Chandler puts it,

Gravity always wins. We are all wrinkling. Our nose and ears never quit growing. It is only a matter of time till that little component that we are basing so much on starts to vanish and must be replaced by attraction founded on character and covenant.

It's also vain in that physical beauty has no value without a foundation of godly character.  Proverbs 11:22 puts it memorably:

'A beautiful woman who lacks discretion is like a gold ring in a pig's snout.'

Dating a gorgeous woman without godly character doesn't make any sense.

Younger guys 'know' this... in theory.  In practice, with our culture's obsession with appearance and our own fallenness, keeping physical appearance in its place is easier said than done.

Let's go back to Proverbs 31:30 - the whole verse this time - for the proper relationship between character and physical beauty when we're evaluating a potential spouse.

Charm is deceitful, and beauty is vain,
    but a woman who fears the Lord is to be praised.

There's no contest.  If beauty and character were to fight, character wins every time.  At least in the long run.

So, Should I Date A Godly Woman I’m Not Attracted To?

Great question.  Lots of guys ask me if they should date a woman they’re not physically attracted to. They usually have someone specific in mind, a friend with godly character.  They have a real chemistry, but ‘I just don’t find her attractive, and don’t want to lead her on.  What should I do?’

My short answer is ‘no, you shouldn’t start dating her.’ Physical attraction isn’t the most important quality in a potential spouse, but your attraction to her does matter.

No woman wants to feel like a consolation prize, someone you ‘should be’ attracted to, but aren’t.  If you pursue the relationship, she will get hurt and you will feel guilty.  Your hearts will get entangled, and significant, emotional pain is likely to occur.

At the same time, I’m not just giving you an easy out, and this decision needs to be set in the bigger context of seeking God’s will.

Here are two suggestions for what to do if you find yourself in this situation so that your expectations for women line up with God’s.

Pursue personal purity

If you’re not physically attracted to a godly woman, I don’t want you to feel guilty.  At least not automatically.  Different guys will be attracted to different women, and that can be from the Lord.

At the same time, we are broken and fallen, and we should be suspicious of ourselves.  Is it possible that you’re not attracted to her because you’re taking your cues from the culture’s standard of airbrushed beauty?

If you’re using pornography or giving into fantasy, now is the time to stop.  Repent when you fail, and receive the forgiveness and new power to obey that God loves to give (1 John 1.9” data-version=”esv” data-purpose=”bible-reference”>1 John 1:9).  Confess honestly to a friend, and ask him to help you in your fight (James 5.16” data-version=”esv” data-purpose=”bible-reference”>James 5:16).

If we resist pornography and an impure thought life, if we ‘flee youthful passions and pursue righteousness, faith, love, and peace, along with those who call on the Lord from a pure heart’ (2 Tim 2.22” data-version=”esv” data-purpose=”bible-reference”>2 Timothy 2:22), we’ll be better able to keep physical beauty and character in their proper balance.  So that we’ll be attracted to godly women, and honor them in how we relate.

Pursue regular friendships with godly women, and hope for more

Again, if you’re not physically attracted to a woman, don’t lead her on.  Don’t spend (much) time with her alone, where she might get the idea you’re singling her out or have interest.

But that’s not necessarily the end of the story.  Chandler gives some more great advice:

Godliness is sexy to godly people. And so, if you get in proximity, and you see the godliness and character of a woman, you begin to take compatibility and godliness and gospel partnership more seriously than just physical attraction…

So, pursue [godly women you’re not physically attracted to] as friends and hope that it grows into more. Want it to grow into more. And I am confident that, over time, character and godliness will win the day.

I can’t promise you that you’ll develop physical attraction for a particular woman, but there’s a good chance you might.  And if you do, you’ll have confidence that it’s a relationship that’s grounded on what really matters and endures: godly character.

For reflection:

  1. What relative importance do you place upon godly character and physical attractiveness when you think about women?  Be honest with yourself – and the Lord.
  2. Are you spending significant alone time with women you’re not attracted to?  Do you need to step back, or change how you’re doing things?
  3. Who are some women you could get to know in group settings, prayerfully hoping God will take one of them in the direction of marriage?

For a great perspective from the woman’s side, check out ‘Should I Date A Guy I Don’t Find Attractive?‘ by Phylicia Masonheimer.

Help me help others by sharing!
  • Thea Williams says:

    Hey, Bryan, I’m posting here rather than on FB, because I think you’ve endured enough diatribe about this piece on that venue! That said, I think your advice is sound, and your responses to your critics, humble and Biblical. I confess, time only allowed me to read the post once, but what I see is your heart being in the right place, trying to advocate for all concerned (the pursuer and the pursued). We can’t help being attracted by some and put off by others; as you say, God made us that way and He understands we’re only dust. I would agree that your suggestion of allowing oneself to be initially only attracted to the character of another can at times blossom into physical attraction as well. A friend once counseled me to look past the physical imperfections of someone I was dating since I was attracted to his personality. She advised me that at times the person becomes more desirable in time as we allow the internal gifts to sort of mesh with the wrapping paper, so to speak. She further speculated that, when a not-so-perfect-looking person feels happy and loved in a relationship, somehow he/she becomes more attractive to the partner. She was right. I ended up marrying him! Disclaimer: I am far from a beauty queen. For all I know, the man I married was having similar conversations with himself about me!

    • Bryan Stoudt says:

      Thank you, Thea, for your kind words. It sounds like you got some great advice, and I love your comment about the internal gifts and wrapping paper. I’m so thankful that ‘though our outer self is wasting away, our inner self is being renewed day by day.’ (2 Corinthians 4:16) Thanks again for reading and interacting with me, Thea!

  • Laura says:

    When my husband started seminary, the president exhorted all the single men in the room to remember that the woman they married would in all likelihood be spending more time with their future children than they would, and that they should pursue someone who would be a powerful witness for Christ in and out of the home, not just a pretty face in the pew on Sunday. I don’t agree with a lot things that seminary president has said, but I agree with that. I appreciate this post, and I think it’s wise advice in the other direction as women look for a potential husband.

    • Bryan Stoudt says:

      Thanks so much, Laura… that was great advice for young guys in seminary. Especially since seminaries don’t often talk about things that aren’t purely academic.

      A few people have expressed interest in a post that would explore reasons why women might not date a godly guy, so I’m going to give that a shot. But I’m going to post a one-question survey people can take in an effort to get some input from women first. Thanks again, Laura.

  • Bryan, this post was well throughout and written. You hit some very key points. I’m in agreement, Godliness always triumphs over the visual. I’ve seen it a thousand times. It’s like… the inner beauty of a woman supersedes the physical, and can’t be overlooked… it’s not fleeting. Thanks for sharing this. God bless.

    • Bryan Stoudt says:

      Hi Shira, thank you for taking the time to read, and sharing encouraging feedback. You’re so right about godly character lasting! Just today, my wife and I visited the restaurant where I proposed to her 22 years ago, and took a few pictures for old time’s sake. We laughed about how we don’t look the same as we did back then, but honestly we’re way more grateful for each other now, despite the obvious signs of age. Like Proverbs 31:30 says, ‘beauty is vain, but a woman who fears the Lord is to be praised.’ Many blessings to you!

  • >